DATE: 4/6/2008 FIRST VIEWING
WHERE: Majestic Theatre, part of the 2008 Wisconsin Film Festival…with Bryan.
This was my lone documentary of the festival. I always feel like I should see more, but usually only end up seeing one, maybe 2, each festival. The topic of this film sounded interesting, and Bryan actually wanted to see this over some of the other ones in this time slot. Going back to the Majestic was pretty neat…I hadn’t seen a movie here for a long time, and hadn’t taken Bryan here since it was a dedicated movie theatre. After waiting for Robyn to come home from out of town, we bolted, parked and walked over. We sat in the balcony, close to the front, with a railing cutting off part of the screen, but that was ok…not as distracting as I expected. Of course, about 20 minutes in, Bryan fell asleep (seeing Nerdcore for Life the night before at 11:15)…so I couldn’t discuss the movie afterwards with him
The crowd was totally into the movie, and in fact, pretty audible in their surprise and disgust for stuff presented. The ladies next to us gasped about every 5 minutes….
THE GOOD: exploration of a hot/controversial topic
THE BAD: digitalization of images; felt manipulated
THE WONKY: Ted Haggard…oh man [in a reprise in his role from Jesus Camp!]
James Carroll really starts off with a bang here. Right away you know that this is going to be a personal journey for him…and his exploration of supported Christian evangelizing at the US Air Force Academy is pretty eye opening stuff. Juxtaposed with interviews of Jewish cadets, Ted Haggard from New Life church the story he tells is chilling - equating fervent faith with being warriors for the cross - instead of love, grace and salvation it seems that fear, exclusion and disgust for those not “in your camp” is the norm.
This launches an exploration of Jewish discrimination by Christianity throughout the ages - one which is as much fascinating as it is abhorrent. A lot of great information is brought up here, a lot explored, a lot of which modern churches would rather not talk about…a checkered history to say the least.
There is a lot to chew on here, and a lot to like, a LOT for discussion. It is too bad, then, that ultimately, there is maybe too much taken on…the focus wanders a bit. Not only that, there seems to be an underlying personal agenda of anti-Catholicism. Maybe I am reading into that, since J Carroll, the author of the book on which this movie is based, grew up strong in the faith as a Catholic, was ordained a priest, became disillusioned with it, especially its stances during the Vietnam war, and blames it in part for a wounded relationship with his father. I couldn’t help but feel there was a little bit of that venom coming through the story.
Also, unfortunately, I felt like there was a bit too much manipulation of the audience. I don’t say that just because my audience was very vocal about a lot of the things presented…
I didn’t like the way that still photos were digitzed/manipulated/photo-shopped to try and create effect…or the seeming digital zoom on the current pope
J Carroll claimed that the robe of Christ was based on something written in the Psalms, as if to heap on the fallacy of its claim as a relic. I think that relic worship is pretty much bullshit myself, but for Carroll, as a former priest, it struck me as a bit irresponsible to claim that, when it IS written about in the New Testament (and as prophecy fulfilled)…the validity of THAT or of how the relics were used…OK, debate that,
I also didn’t agree with one of the narration choices - most non-English speaking people in the film had subtitles- but when we got to a Holocaust survivor who was a child at the time, and he saw his mother for the last time as they were being ushered into Auschwitz. A terribly tragic story…but instead of letting the man speak, we get an Eli Wallach voice over in English relating the story. Not a big deal I supposed (and I like Tuco from the good the bad and the ugly) but it seemed to me like a cheat…
I realize these kind of stories often have personal bents and want to get an opinion across. But in many cases there just seemed too much of one side, too much of only showing so much information to say “see? SEE????” But that is an angle taken, and that’s ok…here is where I would have liked a bit more focus, or maybe a couple movies splitting the topics to cover ground in more detail, and ultimately be more damning, but in a way that allows atonement as opposed to simple revulsion…
The nitpicks aside…I did enjoy the movie, or at least the journey and what the movie was trying to accomplish. There is a lot of important stuff here, and I will probably visit this again, maybe with more people to discuss with next time…
6.5 out of 10